Efficiency evaluate Q1 2024 – Remark: “Contrarian Investing – Simpler stated than carried out”


Within the first 3 months of 2024, the Worth & Alternative portfolio gained  +3,2% (together with dividends, no taxes) in opposition to a achieve of +6,0% for the Benchmark (Eurostoxx50 (25%), EuroStoxx small 200 (25%), DAX (30%), MDAX (20%), all TR indices).

Hyperlinks to earlier Efficiency evaluations may be discovered on the Efficiency Web page of the weblog. Another funds that I observe have carried out as follows within the first 3M 2024:

Companions Fund TGV: +9,0%
Profitlich/Schmidlin: +4,0%
Squad European Convictions: 3,4%
Frankfurter Aktienfonds für Stiftungen: +5,9%
Squad Aguja Particular State of affairs: +1,2%

Paladin One: -5,9%
Alphastars Europe: +0,6%

Gehlen & Bräutigam: -1,3%

Efficiency evaluate:

Inside my subjective small cap peer group, the portfolio carried out barely above common. Total it clearly mirrors the divergence particularly between Massive caps and small caps. Inside my blended benchmark the efficiency for Q1 was as follows:

Eurostoxx 50: +12,8%
DAX: +10,4%
Eurostoxx small: +1,6%
MDAX: -0,4%

As most of my portfolio performs (on goal) within the German/European Small and Midcap area and within the absence of “fortunate punches” like Schaffner and Logistec final 12 months, the efficiency is kind of OK.

WIll it stay like this ? Who is aware of, however from a valuation perspective, I see an increasing number of engaging alternatives in my “circle of competence” which makes me fairly optimistic within the mid- to long run. Quick time period, as at all times, something can occur.

Transactions Q1:

The present portfolio may be seen as at all times on the Portfolio web page.

In Q1, Logistec left the portfolio because of the closing of the take over. Together with dividends, the achieve was round +52%. Not dangerous for round 9 months, however alternatively additionally under my estimate for intrinsic worth.

Two new positions had been entered, each in Germany with Eurokai and Amadeus Hearth. Eurokai is quite a deep worth play, Amadeus Hearth a “first rate high quality at a good value”.

Later within the quarter I diminished the Admiral place to a 5% (from round 6,3%) and I added to Sto (+0,5%) and Energiekontor (+1%).

Common holding is 4,1 years, Money is at ~9% and the ten largest positions are ~51% of the portfolio.

Remark: “Contrarian Investing – Simpler stated than carried out”

Contrarian investing, i.e. shopping for out of favor property which have fallen in value for a while is perhaps one of the in style methods of investing particularly for worth buyers but additionally for a lot of retail buyers, alongside momentum investing, the place one simply buys what’s performing effectively.

In fact, Warren Buffett was/is legendary for Contrarian investing, similar to Amex after the “Salad oil scandal” or shopping for banking shares in the course of the GFC. Different notable Contrarians had been in fact Ben Graham, Peter Cundil or Walter Schloss simply to call just a few.

It sounds very simple: Simply have a look at what has carried out actually dangerous, purchase it and wait till the worth rebounds.

In actuality, that is nonetheless far more difficult: First, that you must make certain that the worth will finally rebound and second, you additionally must be proper about timing.

  1. Will the inventory/asset/market rebound ?

In a whole lot of books you solely learn concerning the profitable examples, like Warren Buffett. Nevertheless, I assume you’ll not learn a ebook concerning the guys who invested a big a part of their portfolios into Russian shares earlier than the assault on UKraine as a result of these shares seemed “so low cost”.

Or these guys who adopted Charlie Munger into Alibaba some years in the past. One of many worst “offenders” on this regard in my opinon is Monish Pabrai along with his extremely dangerous ebook “Dhando Investing”, the place he outlines a extremely dangerous guess on an extremely indebted inventory as a “no draw back” funding, as a result of it labored out. Funnily sufficient, destiny punished him quickly afterward with an enormous loss on an equally “no draw back danger” funding known as Horsehead Zinc. It is a crucial subject to recollect: Simply because a guess labored out, doesn’t imply that there was no danger to start with.

Avoiding worth traps is far tougher than it sounds. Everybody goals of shopping for the following Amazon after the Tech crash, however nobody talks concerning the hundreds of Dot.com firms that didn’t make it. Structural trade poblems usually appear to be non permanent issues to start with.

There are additionally circumstances the place an organization is so fuxxed up that little or nothing may be carried out about it, even when elements of the corporate are OK. Basic Electrical was one instance, or Bayer. Such firms may rebound sooner or later in time however from a a lot decrease degree than everybody expects.

One additionally must look out for any politcal or macro-economic danger which may make an organization, trade and even nation uninvestible for a while to come back. Russia was one instance, China is one other. Sure, perhaps we’ll see a serious rebound in Chinese language shares if pressure will go away round Taiwan. Nevertheless, if the Taiwan concern heats up, there’s a actual danger that international shareholders may find yourself in the same place like these of Russian shares, particularly as you don’t truly personal shares in Chines firms however quite some unique derivatives with Caribean entities as counterparty.

2. Timing of the rebound

One other huge concern with Contrarian investing is timing. You may be proper ultimately, however particularly as an expert cash supervisor, another person may handle your fund in case you don’t get the timing proper.

A variety of the new Dotcom shares that truly survived, took a really very long time to get well. One other sector that impacts me personally is building. After such an extended, low rate of interest fueled, increase, it’d take just a few years till the sector recovers to ranges anyplace close to current peaks.

For a affected person personal investor, with no bossess to please, howveer the timing issue is usually a excellent alternative.

What labored finest for me previously ?

For me, previously the next method labored finest: Search for a really broad and “public” downturn (ideally nation and even continent) after which deal with high quality firms which are comparatively low cost to their intrinsice worth, not on the absolut least expensive shares. My largest “goldmine” clearly was the Euro disaster in 2011/2012.

For the time being, I do have the sensation, that European small caps provide the same alternative than again then but when that’s true we ailing solely be capable of see in just a few years.

Scroll to Top